YourDigits vs PocketSmith: Forecasting vs Fixing
PocketSmith and YourDigits both take budgeting seriously, and they both have strong appeal to Australian and New Zealand users. But they're answering different questions. PocketSmith's defining feature is long-range cashflow forecasting. YourDigits's defining feature is leak detection and priority-ordered fixes. Deciding between them depends on whether you think about money in years or in pay cycles.
The Philosophy Comparison
Neither app hides what it is, which makes the comparison cleaner than most.
PocketSmith: Forecasting First
PocketSmith has been around since 2008, founded in New Zealand. Its positioning centres on cashflow forecasting. The idea is that once your bank data is in, the app projects what your finances will look like months, years, or decades into the future. The projection horizon scales with the plan you're on: six months on the free tier, ten years on Foundation, thirty years on Flourish, sixty years on Fortune.
The rest of PocketSmith is built around supporting that projection. Calendar-based budgets (budgets live on specific dates, not just in monthly totals). Net worth tracking over time. Rollover budgeting (unspent money carries into the next period). A "safe balance" feature that tells you what you can spend today without breaking future plans.
PocketSmith doesn't have a named philosophy like YNAB's "Method." It has a mechanic (the forecast), and everything else is there to feed or read from the forecast.
If you think about your money the way a financial planner does, in terms of trajectories and scenarios stretching years ahead, PocketSmith is doing something nothing else on the market does as well.
YourDigits: The Leak Ladder
YourDigits starts from a different question. Instead of "what will my finances look like in ten years," it asks "what's leaking right now and what do I fix first."
The Leak Ladder is a priority-ordered system of 9 structural financial leaks. Things like no spending plan, no starter emergency fund, missing employer match (or in Australia, super that isn't tracked), high-interest debt at or above 7% APR, no full emergency fund, and so on up to investing beyond retirement.
You take an 11-question audit. The system detects which leaks you have and which rung you're currently on. Every pay cycle, it generates specific tasks with dollar amounts for the active rung. Higher rungs get paused automatically if foundations are still leaking, so you can't accidentally fund investing while a credit card at 22% APR is bleeding you.
No forecasting. No long-range projections. Just: here's what's wrong, here's what to fix this pay cycle, here's the order.
The Real Difference
PocketSmith looks ahead. YourDigits looks at the current rung of the ladder.
If your finances are stable and you're in planning mode ("given what I have, what does retirement look like in 25 years?"), PocketSmith's forecasting is the right tool. It's doing the analysis most other apps can't.
If your finances aren't stable and you're in fix mode ("I have leaks, which one is costing me the most right now?"), YourDigits's priority logic is the right tool. The forecasting is less relevant when the current-cycle leaks are the thing dominating your results.
I built YourDigits because I had the opposite problem from what PocketSmith solves. I'd tracked every personal transaction since 2020 (over 4,600 of them), so I had plenty of data. What I didn't have was a system for deciding which of my leaks to fix first. Tracking showed me where my money was going. It didn't tell me which leak to plug in what order. The Leak Ladder exists because having the data isn't enough if you don't know what to do with it.
PocketSmith takes that same "lots of data" starting point and points it at the future. YourDigits takes it and points it at priority.
Quick Comparison
| YourDigits | PocketSmith | |
|---|---|---|
| Defining feature | Leak Ladder (detect and prioritise 9 financial leaks) | Cashflow forecasting (up to 60 years on top tier) |
| Philosophy | Priority-ordered leak fixing | Forecast-first financial planning |
| How you start | 11-question audit detects your leaks | Connect bank feeds or import CSV, set up budgets on the calendar |
| Each pay cycle | System generates tasks for the active rung | You monitor spending against calendar budgets and review the forecast |
| Input method | Voice entry (5 seconds, on-device) | Bank feeds + manual CSV import |
| Bank feeds | None (by design) | Yes, 49 countries |
| Budgeting style | Pay-cycle, priority-ordered, adaptive | Calendar-based, rollover, flexible period |
| Health score | Yes (0-100, based on leaks) | No (net worth and forecast instead) |
| Projection horizon | Current pay cycle | 6 months (free), 10/30/60 years (paid tiers) |
| Adaptive targets | Yes, adjusts based on your performance | No, you adjust manually |
| Pricing (AUD) | Free tier + $5.99/mo or $39.99/yr | Free tier + $14.95/$24.95/$39.95/mo (3 tiers) |
| Platforms | iOS | Web, macOS, Windows, Linux, iOS, Android |
| Multi-currency | Yes (voice-parsed) | Yes (built-in) |
| AU-specific features | Super tracking, fortnightly pay cycles, AUD native | Strong AU market presence, AU bank feeds |
How You Use Each App
PocketSmith: the flow
You connect your bank accounts (or import CSV if you prefer not to connect). Your transactions come in automatically. You set up budgets on the calendar view, which can be daily, weekly, monthly, or flexible periods. As data accumulates, the forecast engine projects out what your balances, net worth, and cashflow will look like at your plan's horizon.
Most PocketSmith users spend their time in the calendar view or the forecast. The daily interaction is usually "how is the current budget running" plus an occasional check of "what does the next year look like at this pace."
The value scales with how much data you feed it. Fresh accounts with no history give you short forecasts. Five years of clean transaction history gives you trustworthy long-range projections.
YourDigits: the flow
You take the audit. 11 questions, roughly 3 minutes. The system detects your leaks and tells you which rung of the Leak Ladder you're on. You get a Health Score (0-100) and a list of active leaks in priority order.
Each pay cycle, the app generates specific tasks for the active rung. If you're on Rung 4 (high-interest debt), the task is a debt payment with a target dollar amount based on your income and cashflow. If you're on Rung 2 (starter emergency fund), the task is a transfer to your savings with a specific target. You log transactions by voice through the pay cycle (five seconds per transaction, on-device speech recognition, no audio sent anywhere), and the app tracks your progress automatically against the active rung.
There's no forecast. The system doesn't tell you what your net worth will be in 20 years. It tells you what to do this pay cycle so the current rung gets plugged, and then it moves you up.
Who PocketSmith Is Best For
PocketSmith is excellent if you:
- Want to see your finances projected years or decades into the future
- Think about money in terms of long-range trajectories and scenarios
- Have stable income and are in planning mode, not crisis mode
- Want cross-platform access (web, macOS, Windows, Linux, iOS, Android)
- Need bank feed support in multiple countries
- Have a small business and want Xero integration
- Appreciate calendar-based budgeting with rollover logic
- Are willing to invest time learning the forecasting features to get the most out of them
PocketSmith's forecasting is the strongest piece of any budgeting app I've looked at. If that's what you need, nothing else on the market does it as thoroughly, and it's worth the paid tiers to unlock the longer horizons.
Who YourDigits Is Best For
YourDigits is a better fit if you:
- Have active financial leaks you need to fix and want a system that tells you which one to fix first
- Prefer voice-first input over bank feeds or manual CSV imports
- Don't want to share bank credentials with any third party
- Want your budget aligned to your pay cycle instead of the calendar
- Need adaptive targets that adjust when life happens instead of punishing you for missing a week
- Are Australian and want native super tracking plus fortnightly pay cycles
- Want a Health Score that changes as you plug leaks
- Prefer the lower price point ($5.99/mo vs PocketSmith's $14.95+/mo)
YourDigits is iOS-only right now, and it doesn't forecast. But it does something PocketSmith doesn't: it tells you what to fix and in what order. If your finances aren't stable enough to trust a 10-year projection yet, the Leak Ladder is the more immediate tool.
The Honest Trade-Offs
What PocketSmith does that YourDigits doesn't:
- Cashflow forecasting with projections up to 60 years
- Bank feeds in 49 countries
- Cross-platform (web, macOS, Windows, Linux, iOS, Android)
- Calendar-based budgeting with rollover logic and flexible periods
- Net worth tracking over time
- Xero integration (for small business overlap)
- Mature feature set from nearly two decades of development
- CSV import and export
- Advisor access (for users sharing data with a financial adviser)
What YourDigits does that PocketSmith doesn't:
- Automatic detection of 9 financial leaks with priority logic
- Leak Ladder framework (priority-ordered fixes)
- Financial Health Score (0-100)
- Voice-first transaction entry (5 seconds, on-device)
- Pay-cycle aligned budgets with adaptive targets
- Tasks generated automatically for the active rung every pay cycle
- Pause logic (higher rungs hold until foundations are plugged)
- No bank connection required
- Lower entry price ($5.99/mo)
- AU-specific leak for super tracking
The Australian Angle
If you're comparing these two specifically for Australian use, both apps take AU seriously, which is unusual. Most budgeting apps are US-first and treat AU as an afterthought, which is why I maintain a dedicated Best Budgeting App in Australia shortlist that includes both of these plus Frollo and YNAB.
PocketSmith is NZ-founded and has strong AU bank feed coverage. If you need bank feeds from multiple countries (including AU banks) and you want forecasting, PocketSmith is one of the best options in the AU market.
YourDigits is built by an Australian accountant and handles AU-specific leaks natively: super tracking, fortnightly pay cycles, AUD as a native currency, and the "Super Not Tracked" leak is built into the Leak Ladder specifically because roughly 4 million Australians have 2+ super accounts and there's nearly $19 billion in lost super sitting out there (source: ATO lost and unclaimed super data).
Both are legitimate AU choices. The decision isn't "which one is AU-friendly" (they both are). The decision is "which job do you need done."
Not Sure Which Fits?
If you're in planning mode (stable income, long horizons, want to see your financial future), PocketSmith is likely the better pick. Start with their free tier to see the calendar budgeting and the 6-month forecast, then decide if the longer horizons on Foundation or Flourish are worth it.
If you're in fix mode (you have leaks you know about or suspect, and you want a system to prioritise them), start with the Know Your Digits quiz. It's free, takes 3 minutes, no signup, no bank connection. You'll see your leaks and your Leak Ladder rung.
If the Leak Ladder clicks for you, download YourDigits free on the App Store. If the forecasting angle matters more, PocketSmith is a solid choice.
Related Reading
Take the Audit
11 questions. Your score from 0 to 100. A personalized task plan for your next pay cycle.
Download YourDigits Free on the App Store