PocketSmith vs Frollo: Which Australian Budgeting App Should You Pick?
If you're choosing between PocketSmith and Frollo, you're probably Australian, probably serious about managing your money, and probably looking at one of the two as the "local" alternative to the US-first apps that dominate the category. Both apps are legitimate picks. They're built for different people and different problems.
This page is a fair comparison. Neither of these is my product. I'm an Australian accountant who runs a separate app that takes a third approach (more on that at the bottom), but for this comparison I'm going to treat Frollo and PocketSmith as the two real options and help you figure out which fits.
Side A: Frollo
Frollo is Australian-built, free, and Open-Banking-native.
"Free" in Frollo's case means actually free. No premium tier, no in-app purchases, no ads. The business model isn't subscription revenue. Frollo is owned by NextGen, a financial data company, and the consumer app is part of a broader Open Banking ecosystem play. What that means for you as a user is that the full feature set is available without payment.
The core feature is Open Banking connections. Frollo uses the Consumer Data Right (CDR), which is the Australian government-backed framework for sharing bank data. You authorise Frollo to access specific data from specific accounts for a specific time period. You don't share your bank password. You can revoke access at any time. This is materially more privacy-preserving than the screen-scraping or credential-sharing that traditional bank feed aggregators use.
Once your accounts are connected, Frollo handles:
- Automatic transaction categorisation
- Budget tracking and goal setting
- Net worth tracking (bank accounts, investments, assets, liabilities)
- Bill tracking with due date reminders
- Smart alerts (unusual spending, upcoming bills)
- Super tracking (which is rare)
- A PDF financial snapshot (useful for brokers or lenders)
The AU-specific design shows up in small places. Super is treated as a real account type, not an afterthought. AUD is the default. Fortnightly pay is assumed, not a workaround.
Where Frollo is honest about its limits: It's a tracker and budgeter, not a forecaster. It tells you where you are and where you've been. It doesn't project multi-year cashflow scenarios. It also doesn't have adaptive targets, priority-ordered tasks, or a named budgeting philosophy. The interaction model is "log in, see what's happening, adjust if needed."
Side B: PocketSmith
PocketSmith is the opposite end of the spectrum in almost every way.
It's paid (with a limited free tier), it's cross-platform across web and desktop, and its defining feature is cashflow forecasting. Where Frollo shows you today, PocketSmith shows you the next six months, ten years, thirty years, or sixty years depending on your plan. The projection engine is the thing everything else is built around.
PocketSmith was founded in New Zealand in 2008 and has a strong AU/NZ user base. The paid tiers in AUD:
- Free tier: 2 accounts, 12 budgets, 2 dashboards, 6-month projection
- Foundation: AUD $14.95/mo or $9.99/mo annual. 6 connected banks (1 country), 10-year projection.
- Flourish (most popular): AUD $24.95/mo or $16.66/mo annual. 18 connected banks (all countries), 30-year projection.
- Fortune: AUD $39.95/mo or $26.66/mo annual. Unlimited banks (all countries), 60-year projection, priority support.
There's a 33% discount for annual billing and a 14-day money-back guarantee.
The feature set is mature:
- Bank feeds in 49 countries
- Calendar-based budgeting (daily, weekly, monthly, or flexible periods)
- Rollover budgeting (unspent money carries forward)
- "Safe balance" feature that tells you what you can spend today without breaking future plans
- Net worth tracking over time
- Bill scheduling
- Multi-currency native
- Xero integration (useful if you have small business crossover)
- Advisor access (for users sharing data with a financial adviser)
- Web, macOS, Windows, Linux desktop apps, iOS, Android
Where PocketSmith is honest about its limits: It's a forecasting and budgeting tool, not a diagnostic one. It doesn't tell you which leaks in your finances to fix first. It doesn't have adaptive targets or priority-ordered tasks. The bank feeds aren't Open Banking (CDR) based, they use aggregation partners, which is a slightly less privacy-preserving approach than Frollo's. And the paid tiers are meaningfully more expensive than Frollo's total cost (which is zero).
The Gap: What the Two Apps Are Actually For
| Frollo | PocketSmith | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Free (no premium tier) | Free tier + AUD $14.95-$39.95/mo |
| Origin | Australian | New Zealand |
| Bank connection | Open Banking (CDR) | Aggregation partners (not CDR) |
| Defining feature | Free Open-Banking-based tracking | Long-range cashflow forecasting |
| Projection horizon | None (tracks current state) | 6 months (free) to 60 years (Fortune) |
| Super tracking | Yes | No |
| Multi-currency | AUD-focused | Yes (49 countries) |
| Cross-platform | iOS, Android | Web, macOS, Windows, Linux, iOS, Android |
| Xero integration | No | Yes |
| Advisor access | No | Yes |
| Target user | AU consumers who want free, privacy-preserving bank-linked tracking | Serious planners who want long-range cashflow forecasting and sophisticated budgeting |
The clearest way to think about the gap is this: if you asked "what will my finances look like in 20 years at current trajectory," PocketSmith answers that question better than almost any other consumer app. If you asked "am I spending more than I thought on groceries this month," Frollo answers that, free, with Open Banking.
The apps aren't really competing. They're solving different parts of the Australian personal finance problem for different kinds of users.
Who Should Pick Frollo
Frollo is the right choice if you:
- Want a free, full-featured budgeting and tracking app with no paywall
- Care about Open Banking (CDR) privacy and prefer it over traditional aggregators
- Want super tracking built in (it's rare and Frollo does it well)
- Need bill due date reminders and unusual spending alerts
- Want a PDF financial snapshot you can hand to a broker or lender
- Are AU-only and don't need international bank coverage
- Don't need cashflow forecasting or long-range projection
Frollo is also a strong choice for people who want to dip a toe into Open Banking without committing to a paid product first. If the CDR framework is new to you, Frollo is a low-risk way to see what it feels like.
Who Should Pick PocketSmith
PocketSmith is the right choice if you:
- Want to see your finances projected months, years, or decades into the future
- Think in long-range trajectories and cashflow scenarios, not just this month
- Have stable enough income that a multi-year forecast has meaning
- Need cross-platform support across desktop operating systems
- Want calendar-based budgeting with rollover logic and flexible periods
- Have small business or advisor integration needs (Xero, advisor access)
- Are willing to pay for the longer projection horizons on Flourish or Fortune
- Want a mature feature set from a platform that's been iterating since 2008
PocketSmith's forecasting is what you're paying for. Everything else the app does is competent, but the forecasting is the reason to choose it over free alternatives.
The Honest Trade-Offs
What Frollo does that PocketSmith doesn't:
- Completely free, permanently
- Open Banking (CDR) based connections with stronger privacy guarantees
- Native super tracking
- Smart alerts for unusual spending and upcoming bills
- PDF financial snapshot for brokers/lenders
- Australian-owned
What PocketSmith does that Frollo doesn't:
- Long-range cashflow forecasting (6 months to 60 years)
- Cross-platform support including macOS, Windows, Linux desktop apps
- Calendar-based budgeting with rollover and flexible periods
- Xero integration for small business crossover
- Advisor access
- Multi-currency covering 49 countries
- Safe balance feature (how much you can spend today without breaking future plans)
- More mature feature set from nearly two decades of development
The Third Option: No Bank Linking At All
Neither Frollo nor PocketSmith will fit you if you don't want to connect your bank accounts to any third party, full stop. Open Banking is more privacy-preserving than traditional aggregators, but it's still data sharing with a non-bank entity. Some people aren't comfortable with that, and the alternative isn't "use a spreadsheet forever."
YourDigits (my app, I'm disclosing that) takes a different approach: voice-first transaction entry with no bank connection of any kind. You log transactions by speaking them ("spent twelve fifty at Subway for lunch"), on-device speech recognition parses the amount, merchant, and category, and the app tracks your progress against a priority-ordered system called the Leak Ladder. No bank login, no aggregator, nothing leaves your phone.
It's built in Australia, handles AUD natively, aligns to fortnightly pay, and has a super-tracking leak built into the priority system. Pricing is AUD $5.99/mo or $39.99/yr with a free tier. iOS only right now.
The reason I'm bringing it up is that the Frollo-vs-PocketSmith choice usually assumes bank linking is the input method. If you're here because you want a privacy-first alternative and neither Open Banking nor aggregation partners feel right, YourDigits might be the third path. If that's not your concern, Frollo and PocketSmith are both good picks on their own terms.
How to Decide
The simplest test: do you want forecasting or not?
If you want to see your financial trajectory 5 or 10 or 30 years forward, PocketSmith is the answer and the paid tier is worth it for the longer horizons.
If you don't need forecasting and you just want free, privacy-preserving tracking of your current finances, Frollo is the answer and it's hard to beat free.
If you don't want bank linking at all, neither of these is your app, and you should look at a voice-first or manual-entry option instead.
For the broader AU landscape (including YNAB, YourDigits, and the reasons most US apps don't fit Australian needs), I put the full shortlist together at Best Budgeting App in Australia.
Related Reading
Curious which leaks you have?
The Know Your Digits quiz takes 3 minutes and shows you which of the 9 leaks are yours, in priority order.
Find my leaks